The Supreme Court today invited amicus briefing “by interested persons or entities” that would “address[ ] the legal issues raised” by Governor Newsom’s request last Thursday “for a recommendation allowing him to issue a commutation reducing all sentences of death to life in prison without the possibility of parole.” The court also filed a pro-commutation amicus brief that was submitted on Friday. (See Request re: Commutation of death sentences.)
The order’s phrasing — that the issues before the court apparently concern the commutation of “all sentences of death” (emphasis added) — suggests the court’s decision on Newsom’s request might determine the validity of commuting all 548 current California death sentences, not just the 382 that the court is constitutionally required to review.
As we explained last week, the Governor himself preemptively raised and refuted two possible arguments against the commutations.
The amicus brief filed today is from the California Appellate Project, the Habeas Corpus Resource Center, and the Office of the State Public Defender, who say they are “the predominant providers of postconviction representation and assistance to counsel who provide such representation for individuals sentenced to death in California.” The Supreme Court appoints the Resource Center’s executive director. (See also here.) The Governor appoints the State Public Defender, subject to State Senate confirmation. The Appellate Project is a non-profit law firm established in 1983 by the State Bar of California at the request of California’s Chief Justice.
Another amicus brief, on behalf of 19 individuals and presumably also in support of the commutations, was submitted today and will likely be filed.
[November 11 update: the application and proposed amicus brief are here. The application describes the amici as “nineteen professors of law, history, philosophy, and government, who have examined the history of executive clemency in the United States and/or have practical experience in the area.” The brief supports the Governor’s clemency application, saying, “Clemency in capital cases is deeply rooted in the history and traditions of the American people and was adapted from the practice of British monarchs.”]
Before today, it was unclear if the court would accept any briefing regarding Newsom’s commutation request. In 2023, the court denied a district attorney’s motion to present briefing and argument regarding a gubernatorial request for permission to commute a life without parole sentence. (See here.)
Proposed amicus briefs are due in two weeks, by November 24, and the Governor’s “consolidated answer” to those briefs is to be filed 10 days later, by December 4. Newsom leaves office in 55 days and the court will most likely rule on the commutations before then.
[November 12 update: the Sacramento District Attorney’s Office has a Facebook post asking the public to “write or email” the Supreme Court to oppose the blanket commutation and to “[t]ell the court why every case deserves individual review.” The post includes the email addresses of Chief Justice Guerrero and Clerk/Executive Officer Jorge Navarrete. It does not mention that amicus letters and briefs must be served, presumably on the Deputy Solicitor General who is the Governor’s counsel of record for the commutation request (see rules 8.500(g)(1), 8.520(f)(5)), so it’s not known whether any of the justices or their staff will ever see unserved letters or emails sent at the DA’s request.]
[November 16 and 17 update: the Orange County District Attorney’s office has filed an amicus curiae brief opposing Newsom’s commutation recommendation request.]
[November 17 updates: the California Attorneys for Criminal Justice have submitted an amicus brief supporting the commutations. The court today granted permission to file the brief.]
Related:
Governor asks Supreme Court to approve a blanket commutation of 382 death sentences
Supreme Court orders hearing on landmark anti-death penalty writ petition